Who disagrees and why?
By - Sezity_reddit
It looks like you just put the albums in a random order but I don't hate it
W for not instantly trashing on Cherry Bomb
nobody trashes on cb anymore rlly
Tiktok says otherwise lol
tiktok tyler fans kinda dumb though
Fr, Tiktok kinda ruined Tyler's fan base but it make it bigger. Nevertheless proud of tyler for making it this far.
that’s all tiktok is good for. ruining good things and making them way too big
nah IGOR ruined tyler’s fan base lmao, tiktok has just expounded on it
you are the minority
igor brought an entire new side of fans to Tyler since it was so out of left field and different compared to his other shit, makes sense some of them would be annoying statistically, absolutely love th album but it definitely brought most of the “tiktok” kids here
I don’t disagree that it definitely exploded in popularity and brought in a new side of fans, but I don’t think it ruined his fan base. Diverse tastes and opinions are always good, it just becomes bad when people start the dumb fan wars stuff over what is “better”
i swear i see this nigga under every single r/tylerthecreator post have you got a life outside of reddit
hello i am here to spread negativity
Oh no, my worst enemy, negativity! 😱
Listen to the haters 🗣️🗣️🔥🔥
Goblin is NOT better than Bastard lil bro
Bastard is such a rough listen. It’s not bad, but very clearly Tyler’s first mixtape.
Still more interesting than Goblin tbh songs have more variety and more interesting sounds
goblin overhated and bastard overrated. goblin is like #5 in his total album ranking
It's a mixtape bro. It's not gon be a masterpiece
What are you smoking
how many times did you hear Bastard? once? Goblin is so fucking boring and it has like 5 good songs max, Bastard is full of bangers and is the one with the most replay value
Saying Goblin is boring is insanity 😭
It gets old really fast, the shock value can only carry the project for so long. The album looses me after tron cat
I've heard all the albums so many times, including bastard, Its a good album but its not better than his other work. Also I'm not a fan of that level of intensity in his lyrics
goblin is worse for me because bastard has these super raw beats, literally kid tyler working solely with whatever he could get his hands on. i don’t get the same feeling from goblin
yeah the lyrics in that album are wild but the beats and how catchy the songs can be sometimes is what got me vibing, look at AssMilk
Goblin never did this to me bro I'm sorry
Yeah I don’t listen to bastard too much cus it’s just so intense and violent that I’m not much into it. I only found Tyler a year ago though so I don’t have much room to talk
Wolf 1 finally
Based? It’s the token old Tyler fan choice 😭
It kinda feels like you just didn’t want to be basic and made a unique ranking instead
Nah I used to hate CB, But after relistening from a artistic point of view its one of his greatest albums with a mix of hip hop, Rock, rap ETC
my brother in christ hip hop is rap
Rap is hip hop
I would say there is a difference. Hip-hop instrumentals are hip-hop. Not rap. See?
Hip hop is the culture rap is the genre
Fuck these reddit kids down voting you lmao
Tbh Cherry Bomb isn’t even that big of a deal. My main issue with it is Goblin over Bastard
I’m ready for y’all to think I’m a straight tik tok poser but I promise this jus how I feel. I be listening every album to this day consistently. But that said this is my order.
2. Estate Sale
3. Cherry Bomb (would’ve been #2 if CMIYGL didn’t get the deluxe tbh)
5. Flower Boy
6. Bastard (was a close #5 for me)
YES FINALLY SOMETHING WITH WOLF #1 LES GOOO
for me its
id put cherry bomb above igor
Overhated album yet y’all managed to make cherry bomb overrated 😭😭
Fr this is getting outta line. Cherry Bomb is not awful like how it was first received upon release but it sure as hell isn't as good as a lot of people rate it nowadays. It's in the bottom end of Tyler's discography
Fr, at this point it’s so overrated, I can appreciate for what it did to Tyler career but this is no where near his best album 💀💀
In my opinion this album almost put a coffin in Tyler's career. A lot of people stopped really fw Tyler after Cherry Bomb. Then when he dropped Flower Boy it revived his fan base and his career. Then Igor dropped and the rest is history.
Fr, sounds a lot familiar with ye
igor is litreally a perfect album so idk
I think Igor is easily his best album, but i get that people who are into his rap wont have it that high in their personal list. My list would be,
3. Flower boy
5. Cherry bomb
This is the objective quality list, but personal preferences, memories related to songs etc. will definitely change it a lot
Bastard over goblin though
personally my fav js flower boy and id put cherry bomb at five it alright but not his best, then second wolf the third either tes or igor and four either igor or tes
flair is mine.
Ours is pretty similar
Mfer what 😭
Cherry bomb was good but it was not better then Igor
Cherry Bomb doesn’t deserve the hate, it’s basically half noise rock, half R&B, and I’m okay with that. The beats are awesome, and Tyler took a huge swing by making it. I have to respect it for that.
That being said, Igor and CMIYGL Estate Sale are far and away his best albums, absolute masterpieces with zero skips.
Possibly the worst tier list of all time but I respect it
This sub is silly
I think no matter what. Ranking Tyler's albums will receive hate. They're all so different. Plus you got the people that love the older stuff than ones that like newer. If your list is too similar to others you'll get dissed, if its too different. You'll also get dissed. Can't win fr
Nice list but Bastard better than Midblin
How is it better
Goblin and bastard both fire as fuck stop hating
cherry bomb IS NOT better than flowerboy shnawg
I swear I’m the only person who likes goblin
Terrible list my nigga
honestly my exact order
dude this is like actually just an L take
Cherry bomb genuinely has some terrible production, literally being carried by 2 or 3 songs.
You're right, this shit went from overhated to overrated real quick. It's 2nd to last in his discography imo
people try and say its good just to be quirky
Honestly, yeah. People do it with every artist. You see them say "(insert bad album) is not only underrated, it's one of their best!" and eventually that shit catches on with some people lmao
"Cherry Bomb the greatest fucking album since the days of sound" Track 11,0:54/5"34, Line 19.
smuckers and 2seater and deathcamp are all really good though
yup so carried by 2 or 3 songs
Switch estate sale and flower boy and that’s my ranking
Na bastard gotta be in the top 5. This isn’t valid.
I like it besides Cherry Bomb being that high. Either way it's your opinion so how could I be mad about it lol. Mine would be:
2. CMIYGL + Estate Sale
4. Flower Boy
6. Cherry Bomb
most people nowadays hate that I put CB so low but like I said, just my opinion
I disagree with this ranking, but I agree with far more of it than I do the general consensus on his albums. It’s cool to see someone with the balls to actually form their own opinion rather than just following the hoard.
My ranking would be:
1. Cherry Bomb
4. Flower Boy
5. CMIYGL (including estate sale)
switch Igor and wolf and goblin and bastard and thats my order
goblin over bastard is crazy
Cherry Bomb at #1 is wacky tacky dawg 😭😭😭😭
Switch goblin and bastard and I completely agree
2. CMIYGL + The Estate Sale
4. Flower Boy
5. Cherry Bomb
switch estate sale and bastard
Goblin over Estate Sale?
Cherry Bomb dickriders are the worst. Plus Bastard is better than both that and Goblin.
Cool and when did i ask for you to insult me for liking a different thing?
Bastard is #1
Bastard is my fav Tyler album but it’s not #1
What is blud blabbing ab 🗣🗣🗣🔥🔥🔥
Goblin Bastard underated
Cherry bomb tour was when I first saw Tyler so it’s always my #1
Yooooouuuuuuuu ahhhh ahhh ahahahahahhhhh
move flower boy to 7, bastard to 6, and goblin to 5 for me. i support cherry bomb #1!!!!
Flower boy at 7 is honestly crazy
Cherry bomb should have been number 1 😤
True but wolf is straight 10/10s
Wolf has some good songs but my personal favorite album will always be Cherry bomb it’s just so experimental and different.
how is that 1 so big
dang it forgot hashtag did that
I don’t agree, but i understand
Truthfully being a Tyler fan since 2011, I never gave cherry bomb a full listen.
Most people say opinions are right to the people who have them, but mfer your opinion is wrong 😭
Goblin is too low for me personally but conventionally good list
I like how the list looks and I agree that wolf is number 1
No way I found someone with the same Tyler taste as me
Lol I'm here
Wrong they’re all #1
Cherry bomb the best
you’re right, it’s really bad
not bad but I’d definitely switch Igor with Cherry Bomb
Honestly, kinda valid.
I disagree with the list but in fairness if Tyler put out cherry bomb after flower boy/igor people would’ve treated its abrasive sound way more seriously
sorry bro but correct order is
then anything else
I say that and Wolf was my first CD I ever bought, but it just doesn’t hit the same as it did when I was a teenager.
Genuinely idk how to tell you this this is later the most basic list to ever exist, everybody and their moms (including me) has this list with the top 3 being in different places 😭
Bastard is much better than goblin
Goblin is way too long and and the songs sound too similar while Bastard has more variety and interesting sounds, and it has that more homemade vibe.
Bastard is like the original Evil dead it’s corny and very amateur but you feel the sheer passion that went into every aspect, and it’s charming in that way.
while Goblin is one of the nightmare on elm street sequels, it’s technically superior and it tries to double down on everything the original did but in doing so looses the charm and just kinda comes off forced and but it definitely still has its high points
I agrre but cherry bomb imo a lil lower
fuck u/spez, move to lemmy -- mass edited with redact.dev
At least the bottom two are correct !!!!
So it jus fuck wolf ig
Look at the top
Brah gonna get a shit ton of hate rn, but how is flower boy 5th i would literally put that first. There's not a single song in that album that doesn't hit
only thing i have a problem with is, why is flower boy so low? is it nostalgia or just u don’t like where this flower blooms?
I love FB its just not as good, If I think about it its probably 4
I’d say personally I’d swap cherry bomb and wolf and swap bastard and goblin. Otherwise I agree
This is objectively correct, the only complaints are flower boy should be at 4 imo and bastard is way better than goblin
Nah, you do you
I don’t really care as long as wolf is 1-3
You will, and you deserve it
Actual facts 💯
Bastard should be above goblin
Imo flower boy is arguably his best album
switch wolf with cherry bomb and then switch wolf and igor and you have my exact top 3 (the only valid ranking)
Honestly just switch cherry bomb and cmiygl and I agree
I think flower boy should be a bit higher. Not second or first place, I like that part of the list, but at third.
I want to be mad but actually this is spot on.
I'd put Flower Boy higher if it was my list. Love Cherry Bomb in the top 2
The more I listen to WOLF the more I appreciate it
It's Def top 3 for me
urgh. i fuckin love wolf and cherry bomb tho
guys why do you hate flowerboy?
W for not hating cherry bomb
Not an outrageous list
Speak your truth, glad to see a list not hating Cherry Bomb though
I know mines kinda basic but here’s mine
2. Flower Boy
7. Cherry Bomb
1. Call Me If You Get Lost/The Estate Sale
2. Flower Boy
3. Cherry Bomb/Wolf
I honestly think most of Tyler's albums are mid to great.
Bastard, Goblin and Cherry Bomb are all mid,
the rest of the colletion is pretty great.
But then again, I genuinely like IGOR more than Flower Boy, which I personally think is like my least favorite Tyler Album. Not that it's bad, but I genuinely like WOLF, IGOR, CMIYGLand The Estate Sale more than what is considered Tyler's peak album.
My point is, no one should cook you for having an opinion. This opinion you got here? It's alright.
Switch Bastard and Goblin then it would be my exact ranking.
finally some cherry bomb love!!
To each their own fr
No hate, I side with you.
You got it right with wolf but bastard deserves better
i dont really care about the top 5 but there is no world where bastard is worse than goblin
People need to learn and realize that music is subjective.
Cherry bomb at 2 is based
Igor is definitely first but go off
Bastard is like top three
Goblin is definitely above cherry bomb and Cmiygl
I think I would put Wolf at #1 too because that was the first album by Tyler that I thoroughly enjoyed because it was a huge shift (imo) in his music. You can tell he really thought out details etc. it also was an album I attribute to a significant time in my life.
Nah if this is your list, then it’s fine. It’s your opinion!
Nah don’t really care about other peoples opinions
Is this your list of favorites or is it your list of what should be considered the best?
Honestly, I agree alot with this, my ranking is really similar. Ngl I wish I could see people with this kinda taste in Tyler's discography more often. A lot of people hive-mind the fuck out of each other here, so it always feels like the same opinions from everyone and I never get to hear a unique take on Tyler's music.
1. Flower boy
2. Cherry bomb
Honestly for the most part, I agree
Pretty good ranking ngl
I’d swap some shit but wolf and cherrybomb def top 2
Flower boy isn't number one so bad list.
Cherry Bomb is the best thing he's ever blessed us with. Nothing better
Everything looks just like in my mind, I would only change bastard over goblin
I like wolf better than Cherry Bomb, but I hate when people have wolf as the best because that tells me a lot about them
So either you are an OF fan that grew up or you started listening to Tyler and discovered his other stuff lol