T O P
myipodclassic

I love it, one of my favorite albums of the year so far. The style is a bit different but still sounds very Idle to me. “Already” and “Escape” fit right in with my previous favorites like “Dahlia” imo. And “Never Stop Me” is my most-played song of the year lol. But everyone’s entitled to their opinion! Keep listening to their older stuff if you enjoy it more 🙂


Significant_Canary68

I personally loved TOMBOY!


imzoo00_

Oh cool! I did really like Shuhua's verse in that song. But then... I'm one of the people still hanging on for a Shuhua solo track 😅 (Which is... apparently controversial? People normally get weirdly annoyed when I say this)


LittleShinySun

I think there are *very* few idol groups that can pull off pop punk and for me G - IDLE isn't one of them. ​ Although I did love their outfits for this era!


akoishida

I didn’t enjoy tomboy. I couldn’t stop thinking that the chorus melody thing was a copy of bad guy


Dr-DrillAndFill

Really ? What's Bad Guy from?


akoishida

bad guy by billie eilish


Dr-DrillAndFill

( why did someone down vote me ? ) Oh, yeah I don't really listen to her which is why I didn't know. Thanks !


akoishida

you’re welcome! and not sure why you got a downvote but I will upvote you to counteract it :)


Dr-DrillAndFill

Thanks ! Maybe they don't like Billie Elish. They downvoted you too I think.


lunachappell

I just think the group doesn't hit us hard since one of their main vocalists was literally kicked out of the group it doesn't help that she was also my bias


Ok_Dance_7666

Uhh soojin was like 4th in terms of vocals. Their top 3 vocalists are still there


lunachappell

But even so she was my bias as well as for some reason when a member leaves a group I just lose a lot of interest in that group cuz it doesn't feel like they're complete anymore and it always feels like they're missing something


XbogongSong

Well even tho she wasn't the main vocalist, Soojin used to balance the other members' vocals, and I agree that now their songs sound like something is missing...


symitwo

Very much. Already is a banger, then I sleep


Dr-DrillAndFill

Yeah. IMO the only note worth tracks are Tomboy and Escape. Kinda came to expect more from them, and we waited so long too.


XbogongSong

To be honest, I'm kinda shocked that you said it sounds like "other generic pop music"! Don't get me wrong I respect your opinion but I just didn't expect that! Simply cause "Vilain dies" surely isn't generic *(at least that's what I think)*, I would kinda agree that "Liar" sounds like a KDA song *(but also that's soyeon who made it so understandable).* For "Polaroid", that song lyrics felt so much like they were talking to Soojin *(But I don't know who knows? right? \*cries\*).* "Already" and "Escape" sounds so much like Gidle song as they had some songs before that gave similar vibes! And I guess all the songs were showcasing lots of the members' voices, mostly Minnie, but some showed Shuhua voice *which I loved so much !* Again, this is your own opinion, maybe you felt something missing since Soojin's voice kinda used to balance the other members'.