T O P
EpicThug21

Assalāmu ʿalaykum  I understand your concern. As for the trolls, the moderators try their best to deal with them as much as possible. However sometimes we get busy and aren't able to respond quickly. I recommend that if you do see trolls, the best way to get rid of them is to use the report feature for both comments/posts, that really helps.


Cheap-Experience4147

Note : My comment can be appear as harsh and it’s not what I want (english is not my first language). I hope however that you get the point


EphemeralAroma

What are the other two languages you speak, if I may ask?


Cheap-Experience4147

Arabic and French


some__muslim

It's like you think that closing down this subreddit will stop islamophobia or will stop Muslims' being exposed to it. No matter where you are you'll probably find islamophobia at some point as a test, so this subreddit (which isn't that bad imo) being open or closed won't change that; it's a space for Muslims so it'll attract islamophobes like any other. And if you think their moderation isn't enough you could just ask for more mods, but I don't think the issue is as big as you make it out to be..


Cheap-Experience4147

The opposite way : This sub is not necessary for Islam or for the Muslim. If it’s not necessary it should at least have a more benefit than fasad : Actually it’s the opposite (in my opinion). And a lot of sub in reedit about Islam (including one with like 4 time the users of this one) have better moderation. The issue is big : Almost not a single post in this sub is free from insult, misinformation, etc…and people even ask for more moderation a lot of time (sometime it’s insult that aren’t even remove hours after their post and others time just misinformation from disbeliever that are literally actif each day and have history only to insult islam (like in the previous post about zakat) : And guess what -> They are not ban from this sub and still post here.


some__muslim

A thing I fear about more moderation is that they'll be against the more controversial parts of Islam and we'll see more censorship. Since Reddit and Western-Muslims are more liberal-leaning I can see this happening here as it does on other Islamic subs with more users and with probably more mods. But for the few times I've seen straight-up blasphemous content I do agree it should be removed sooner, but I haven't seen it as much (not nearly in "every post") as you have... What's the zakat post? And which part of it was that bad? If someone made the wrong assumption you can correct them as a response.. but sometimes more people will agree with the wrong thing, which is unfortunate, but as long as you've done your part by sharing the correct advice with Quran and hadith support the rest is up to Allah Ta'ala. If you see bad information here, imagine how bad it is with their families, or in their communities. It's best to take the opportunity to correct them imo, and inshaAllah they can accept the correction and share it with others.


Cheap-Experience4147

One user actif on sub specialised against islam and muslim reply in this zakat polls and try to convince us that it’s not from Islam but from the hadith only [when the Hadith is also a primary source and even more it’s also in the Quran] But it was not the worst exemple, I agree : I have see worst and more numerous comments…It was just what triggers me to make this post


some__muslim

I mean whether you're in these subreddits or with a group of Muslims in person, someone can share this opinion. Seems like a test for everyone else from Allah Ta'ala. So it's better imo to correct the person (in this case with Quran evidence) than to just shut him up, since you give advice (which is a good deed) and inshaAllah he and some others may be guided.


Cheap-Experience4147

I pretty agree with you : But the point that I am talking about is clear non muslim that try to either spread fasad and misinformation or just came to insult (I am not talking about heretical -> That a point that can benefit us and them by reply to them like you said)


some__muslim

Those usually get very downvoted or sometimes removed by mods, and may Allah protect us from going astray.


Shahid9s

You are right. I have reported users and commenters for insulting Allah, Quran, and the Prophet, and I didn't see any action taken against the users. But I saw one of my posts removed because the subject said it was shirk to bow to people.